Toto not an Island: Before you declare Wadada a failure, check the facts, the record must speak
By Sam Israel
Public debate is healthy in a democracy, but criticism must be founded on facts, fairness and a proper understanding of the issues. The recent publication in the social media declaring that Toto Local Government Area has rejected Senator Ahmed Wadada Aliyu raises important questions, but it also presents a one-sided account that deserves a comprehensive response
First, who authorised the writer to speak for the entire population of Toto? Has a credible opinion survey been conducted? Have traditional rulers, community leaders, youth organisations, women groups and other stakeholders been consulted? It is misleading to convert the opinion of an individual or a political interest group into the collective position of an entire local government
THE KEFFI–NASARAWA–TOTO–ABAJI ROAD: A PROJECT THAT MUST NOT BE IGNORED
One major intervention that deserves attention is the Keffi–Nasarawa–Toto–Abaji federal road project. Senator Wadada has been associated with efforts to facilitate attention to this important road corridor, including engagement with the Minister of Works and the Nasarawa State Government during project inspection.
This road is strategically important to Toto and its neighbouring communities. It has implications for transportation, commerce, agricultural activities, access to markets and the movement of people.
It is therefore unfair to discuss development in Toto without considering the importance of this federal infrastructure intervention and the Senator’s facilitation efforts.
EDUCATION, WATER AND STREETLIGHTS
The Senator’s interventions in education and community infrastructure should also be assessed beyond the few examples mentioned by the critic.
I will highlight some because they are too many to give details in this write up.
- Sunk motorized solar borehole at Government Secondary School GSS Toto.
- Sunk motorized solar borehole at Toto North.
- Sunk motorized solar borehole at Anguwan Mada Gadabuke.
- Sunk hand pump borehole at Kenyehu.
- Sunk motorized solar borehole at Daisu.
- Sunk hand pump borehole at Rugan Ali Barnoma, Karmo.
- 10 solar street lights at Kofa, Toto town.
- 10 solar street lights at Gwargwada, Gadabuke.
- 10 solar street lights Anguwan Madugu, Toto town.
- 10 solar street lights at Umaisha town.
- 10 solar street lights at Ugya.
- Construction of a block of classrooms with headmaster’s office, furniture and solar lights at Toto west primary school, Toto.
- Construction of a block of 2 classrooms with headmaster’s office, furniture and solar lights at Zamfara Primary School, Gadabuke.
- Renovation of Dausu Secondary School through N – Care, Nasarawa State.
- Renovation of examination hall building at Government Secondary School Nakuse.
- Renovation of a block of 5 classrooms with headmaster’s office at Government Secondary school Karmo.
- Scholarships to numerous indigent students.
On constitutional projects under health sector in Toto Local Government Area, the following hospital equipment to General Hospitals in Toto, Gadabuke and Umaisha are as follows:
- 8 Hospital Bedframes.
- 8 Hospital bedside drawers.
- 8 Hospital orthopedic mattresses
- 2 Drip stand
- 1 Neonatal incubator.
- 1 Weighing scale with stand/holder.
- 1 Medical oxygen cylinder
- 3 Ambulances
- 2 Larynoscope
- 2 Surgical scale/Blade/holder
- 1 Surture surgical kits
- 2 Hospital bed refrigerators
- 4 Wheel chairs
- 4 Sphygmomanometer
- 1 Medical stestoscope
- 1 Nursery cots with mattresses and net
- 1 Thermometer oral
- 1 Thermometer rectal.
Fund donations, construction work and personal contributions in Toto Local Government Area are listed below:
- Purchase computer desktop system to NIMCO Toto LA office.
- Purchase 5 sewing machines, 5 grading machines and the sum of 300 thousand Naira contributed to Toto women associations.
- Donated 1 million Naira to Toto central mosque to repair their solar in Toto.
- Donated 2 million Naira to Adadu community to complete their mosque.
- Donated 1 million Naira to Shege community to repair their solar 4 boreholes and building materials for the affected victims of crisis.
- Donated 1 million Naira to Katakpa community to purchase zinc, beddings and building materials for the affected victims of crisis.
- Contributed 500 thousand Naira to Mikagye festival in Toto.
- Contributed 300 thousand Naira to Irewha Cultural festival in Shafa Abakpa
- Donated 1 million Naira to Toto Baptist Association for the building of its new secretariat in Toto.
- Donated 2 million Naira to Shafa Abakpa – Sofiyo to purchase zinc, nails and cement for the affected victims that their houses were destroyed by wind storm.
- Contributed 2 million Naira to Toto central mosque renovation.
- Contributed 2 million Naira for the fencing of new Kara market in Toto.
- Contributed 2 million Naira to timber association to purchase land.
- Donated 1 million Naira to Gbyaji in Gadabuke.
- Construction of two bridges along Warkata village of Gadabuke at the cost of 20 million Naira.
- Donated 500 thousand Naira to Umaisha Development Association.
- Donation of 1.5 million Naira to Egbira Youth Association.
- Donation of truckloads of fertilizer and other farming equipment to farmers in Toto Local Government Area. The list is endless.
Due to lack of space to write everything done in Toto Local Government Area, I urge the people of Toto and indeed lovers of truth to read the interim score card of Senator Ahmed Wadada Aliyu which has been made public .
It is also worth mentioning that similar projects and programs have been done in Keffi, Karu, Kokona and Nasarawa Local Government Areas.
These are identifiable community interventions. Whether they are sufficient to meet every development need in Toto is a legitimate question, but pretending they do not exist would be equally misleading.
The construction and renovation of public schools, provision of boreholes and installation of streetlights are important aspects of grassroots development.
WHAT ABOUT THE PEOPLE AFFECTED BY THE SHAFA ABAKPA WINDSTORM?
Another intervention raised in the Senator’s record of engagement with communities is the provision of palliatives to residents of Shafa Abakpa following a devastating windstorm.
When natural disasters affect families, the immediate responsibility is to provide assistance and help affected people recover. Such humanitarian interventions should form part of an honest assessment of representation, alongside infrastructure and empowerment programmes.
YOUTH AND WOMEN EMPOWERMENT MUST ALSO COUNT
Representation is not restricted to constructing buildings and roads. It also involves opening opportunities for people to become economically independent.
Senator Wadada’s empowerment programmes have included vocational equipment, agricultural support, financial assistance and opportunities for young people and women.
Reports on his first 18 months in office also documented more than 80 pensionable employment opportunities across the senatorial district.
Permanent and pensionable appointments, are properly documented in Senator Ahmed Wadada Aliyu’s scorecard.
THE GOVERNORSHIP QUESTION: EQUITY AND POLITICAL ROTATION
There is also an important political dimension to the debate.
Nasarawa State has three senatorial districts: North, South and West. The argument for the 2027 governorship to move to Nasarawa West is based on the principle of political equity and the rotation understanding advocated by several state stakeholders.
Former APC National Chairman, Senator Abdullahi Adamu, and Governor Abdullahi Sule have publicly discussed the argument for giving Nasarawa West an opportunity to produce the next governor.
The position is that political equity requires the western zone, which has not produced a governor over twenty years since Senator Abdullahi Adamu.
Senator Ahmed Wadada Aliyu is from Nasarawa West and is among the political figures associated with this conversation.
A CALL FOR RESPONSIBLE PUBLIC DEBATE
The writer who declared that Toto has rejected Wadada should provide evidence of that assertion. How many communities were consulted? What was the methodology? Where are the findings?
Equally, those defending the Senator must be prepared to provide project locations, completion records, beneficiary lists and employment documentation. The list of several interventions by Senator Ahmed Wadada Aliyu are all there for verification by doubting Thomases. Public accountability requires evidence from everyone.
Toto deserves development. Its people deserve effective representation, better schools, accessible roads, potable water, employment opportunities and improved living conditions.
The appropriate question is not whether every intervention has solved every problem. It is whether the interventions have been properly documented, implemented and evaluated, and what additional work remains to be done.
CONCLUSION
Political disagreement should never become an excuse for denying documented public interventions or presenting unverified opinions as the collective voice of an entire community.
The people of Toto have every right to demand more from their representatives. They equally have the right to examine the available evidence and make their own independent assessments.
In the final analysis, the development of Toto should be bigger than political personalities, and accountability should be demanded from every public officeholder.
Let the facts be presented, let the records be examined, and let the people make their own informed judgment.
Toto deserves facts, fairness, accountability and development—not political exaggeration.
Israel JP is the Senior Special Assistant to Senator Wadada